Why do you prefer MX over Debian or Mint (or others)?

Here you can just talk about MX or post interesting topics about what you have done in MX that you want to share with others. Other non-MX topics can be discussed within the Rules of the Forum.
Message
Author
User avatar
DukeComposed
Posts: 1506
Joined: Thu Mar 16, 2023 1:57 pm

Re: Why do you prefer MX over Debian or Mint (or others)?

#21 Post by DukeComposed »

asqwerth wrote: Mon Sep 25, 2023 8:01 am For Mint, I really liked Mint 17 but Mint 18 just left me with a "meh" feeling. It wasn't that it was bad or anything. I just didn't see the point of keeping it when MX was working well and Neon filled the "Ubuntu" slot in my distro collection, while Void filled my "Cinnamon DE" slot.
The same thing happened to me with Mint 17 and 18. I had done a little experimentation around Mint 14 or so, but when Ubuntu initially began making moves to support ZFS in their kernel, using an Ubuntu-based distribution became an appealing idea to me. I eventually worked out a procedure to create a ZFS-on-root Mint install with full-disk LUKS encryption: a user-friendly and capable setup that was still secure enough to put on a laptop and not really worry about using it on a public wifi connection.

My computing needs are pretty basic. I need a decent terminal for Perl and shell commands, a compiler, Remmina for remoting, and something to play music and videos. Mint covered all of those without the need to relearn too many basic desktop management skills like if I'd gone with a distro that uses Fluxbox, Openbox, or a tiling window manager like cwm or awesome.

Mint 17/18 was also the era when systemd became the default init system for Ubuntu, so by the time Mint 19 came around, I was already looking for a replacement. But alas, there weren't any distributions out there that were friendly to folks with a Debian background, came with an assortment of common applications for most use cases, automatically handled wifi and networking out of the box, used a familiar DE like Xfce, and looked and felt composed and polished, and didn't rely on systemd.

When I discovered MX Linux, I almost fell out of my chair.

That was sometime circa MX 18.3. There are hundreds of distributions out there. MX Linux is an environment. It's a solution.

User avatar
davidy
Posts: 818
Joined: Sat Jul 03, 2021 1:59 pm

Re: Why do you prefer MX over Debian or Mint (or others)?

#22 Post by davidy »

When I needed a transition from winblows back to linux, and I needed one for the long haul, MX simply worked OOB as they say with the hardware I needed it to run on. After a year or so I realized the true power of the snapshot tool was it's ability to clone the OS to an entirely different pc, and again, everything just worked. MX is NOT a follower, it's a leader. Something of a prerequisite besides xfce itself. The fact it's 'debian' makes no difference whatsoever. I could have cared less if it was a new filesystem on top of a whatever iso spin. It worked when I needed it and does everything I need it to when I need it to. PERIOD Mx really is a special iso in a sea of them. But then again anything that removes windows is special. Whatever flips your pancakes.
Sys76 LemurPro-mx-23.4, EliteMinis HM90-mx-21.3, Deskmini UM350-phoenixLite win10, Qnap 12tb nas, Protectli FW4C-opnsense(=゜ω゜)

zero privacy = zero security . All MX'd Up
UAP = up above people

PlatinumArts
Posts: 55
Joined: Wed Mar 07, 2018 12:08 pm

Re: Why do you prefer MX over Debian or Mint (or others)?

#23 Post by PlatinumArts »

Wow I just want to thank you all so much for all of this amazing insight. I couldn't even last a week on Mint knowing what I was missing in MX. The biggest thing being how well MX handled my Nvidia Quadro 2000. And MX is so snappy that it actually messes with my brain because it is moving faster than my brain is processing the clicks, haha.

I really appreciate reading all of this because as someone new to MX, and a bit out of touch with the Linux scene I'm learning so much. Of course I could read more of the manual but in my opinion nothing beats people's personal experiences.

I also welcome any insight you might have as far as tips. I recently learned I could put the "applications" menu onto my taskbar and that has been life changing! I actually have both "menus" now since I'm not 100% on board with the new default XFCE menu and I'm hoping I can find a way to tweak it more.

Thank you so much for sharing your stories and insights and I hope to hear more! They are so fascinating!

Post Reply

Return to “Community Fun”